The RÖDL website uses technical cookies and cookieless tracking technology to keep anonymous statistics on web traffic. This helps us improve our website and the user experience. You have the option to refuse the use of this technology for statistical purposes. For more, please refer to the information available HERE.



Unannounced Inspections in the Czech Republic: How Can Companies Protect Themselves and Their Trade Secrets?

​​​​An unannounced inspection (commonly referred to as a "dawn raid") can catch virtually any company off guard, including one that complies with the law and has robust internal procedures in place. An inspection may be triggered not only by a company's own conduct but also by suspicions relating to its business partners.

Every company should therefore be prepared for an unexpected visit from inspectors. Well-designed internal procedures and properly trained employees can significantly reduce the risk of unnecessary complications and uncontrolled disclosure of sensitive business information.

What are dawn raids, and who can conduct them?
In the Czech Republic, the term "dawn raid" has traditionally been used primarily in competition law. It refers to unannounced inspections carried out by the Czech Office for the Protection of Competition (ÚOHS) or, where applicable, the European Commission.

Their primary purpose is to investigate potential infringements of competition law, including price-fixing, market-sharing arrangements and abuses of a dominant position.

During such an inspection, officials may enter a company's business premises, examine documents, email correspondence, computers and mobile phones, and make copies of business records. Under certain conditions, they may also seal offices or documents.

As a rule, the ÚOHS does not need prior judicial authorisation to inspect business premises. However, it must have specific grounds for doing so and must remain within the stated purpose of the inspection.

In other words, an inspection cannot be used as an unrestricted search for any possible wrongdoing by the company.

What are the limits of unannounced inspections?
The powers of inspecting authorities are not unlimited. Both Czech and European courts have repeatedly emphasised the need to protect the rights of companies subject to inspection.

For example, in the DELTA PEKÁRNY case, the European Court of Human Rights highlighted the importance of effective judicial protection against disproportionate intrusions into business premises.

The Court of Justice of the European Union has likewise made clear that inspection authorities must adhere to the purpose of the investigation and may not use it as a pretext to deliberately search for evidence relating to a different suspicion already known to them.

The Czech Supreme Administrative Court and Constitutional Court have also repeatedly stressed that an inspection must be based on sufficient grounds and that its scope must correspond to the matters actually being investigated. The Constitutional Court has, for example, pointed out that suspicions raised by competitors, if insufficiently verified, may not in themselves justify a dawn raid.

The practical lesson for companies is clear: they must provide the cooperation required by law while also remaining alert to any overreach by the authorities.

How can trade secrets be protected during a dawn raid?
One of the greatest risks of an unannounced inspection is that sensitive commercial information may be disclosed.

Trade secrets may include customer databases, pricing calculations, business strategies, profit margins, technical processes or information about planned investments.

For such information to qualify for legal protection, however, merely labelling it "confidential" is not enough. A company must also take reasonable steps to protect it, for example by restricting employee access, using non-disclosure agreements or implementing appropriate data security measures.

The fact that a document contains trade secrets does not, by itself, entitle a company to refuse to make it available to inspectors.

However, inspection authorities must comply with the statutory rules governing the protection and subsequent use of confidential information. Companies should therefore expressly identify any trade secrets and request appropriate safeguards, particularly if the documents are subsequently disclosed to third parties. Particular care should be taken with communications with lawyers, which are subject to special legal protections.

Dawn raids in a broader sense: What if the tax authority arrives?
Businesses may face similarly unexpected visits in connection with the administration of taxes.
Although the term "dawn raid" is mainly associated with the ÚOHS in Czech legal practice, in a broader sense it may also encompass unannounced on-site inquiries by the tax authority.

A tax authority may visit a company's business premises without prior notice, request accounting records or other business documents, and examine facts relevant to the administration of taxes.
It is important, however, to distinguish between an on-site inquiry and a tax audit.

An on-site inquiry is primarily intended to gather information and evidence, whereas a tax audit involves a more detailed examination of whether the company has correctly fulfilled its tax obligations.

The Supreme Administrative Court has repeatedly emphasised that the tax authority must not use an on-site inquiry as a means of conducting what is effectively a tax audit without complying with the rules governing the commencement and conduct of a tax audit.

At the same time, the Constitutional Court has confirmed that a specific suspicion of a breach of tax law is not required to initiate a tax audit. Nevertheless, the tax authority must still act lawfully and proportionately.

Protecting trade secrets is equally important during tax inquiries. Although the tax authority may require access to sensitive commercial information, the information obtained is protected by a statutory duty of confidentiality.

Searches in criminal proceedings: What if the police arrive?
An unannounced intervention may also occur in connection with criminal proceedings. In residential premises, this will typically take the form of a search of a dwelling; in company offices or business premises, it will instead be a search of other premises or land. Both types of search generally serve the same purpose: to locate and seize items relevant to criminal proceedings, including documents and electronic data. A search may also affect a person or company that is not itself suspected of criminal conduct.

Searches in criminal proceedings are most commonly conducted on the basis of a written court order. Those affected must submit to a lawful search, but they also have the right to legal assistance, to be present during the search under the conditions laid down by law, and to have seized items properly recorded. However, the obligation to submit to a search does not entail an unlimited duty to actively contribute to one's own incrimination.

It is therefore important during a search to distinguish between situations where the person concerned is required to cooperate by law and those where it is appropriate to exercise the right against self-incrimination, for example by declining to give evidence during questioning conducted before the search.

Companies should also pay close attention to which documents and information the authorities seize during a search. If documents contain trade secrets, that fact should be expressly brought to the authorities' attention and entered in the official record. The presence of trade secrets does not automatically prevent seizure, but the authorities must ensure that their actions do not go beyond what is necessary.

Communications with a lawyer require particular attention. If such communications are among the documents to be seized, this should likewise be expressly pointed out, as communications relating to the provision of legal services may benefit from enhanced legal protection, particularly in view of the lawyer's duty of professional confidentiality.

The protection of this information should not end once documents have been taken away. If a search results in the seizure of documents or other items that are unrelated to the suspected criminal activity and are not needed for the criminal proceedings, their return may be requested. If copies of such documents have also been made, it is advisable to seek a review of whether their continued retention and use are justified. Returning the originals does not, in itself, protect information that remains in the copies.

How should companies prepare for an unannounced inspection?
Companies should establish procedures in advance for handling an unannounced visit by inspectors. In particular, employees should know whom to contact, how to handle requests for documents and how to flag information containing trade secrets.

If an inspection does take place, we recommend following these principles:
  1. Verify the inspectors' identities, their authority and the scope of the inspection. Establish which authority is conducting the inspection, what its purpose is and which matters it concerns.
  2. Contact a lawyer without delay. Having a lawyer present can help ensure that the inspection remains within the limits of the law. However, the inspecting authority may not always be required to wait for the lawyer to arrive.
  3. Do not obstruct the inspection. Do not delete documents, move data or otherwise interfere with the inspection. Failure to cooperate may result in substantial fines.
  4. Identify trade secrets and confidential information. If a document being examined contains sensitive information or communications with a lawyer, expressly draw the inspectors' attention to this and consult your legal adviser on the next steps.
  5. Monitor the inspection and keep detailed records. Record which documents have been examined or copied, ask for an accurate inventory of all materials taken and request that any objections be entered in the official record.
  6. Address how documents will be handled afterwards. Following the inspection or search, seek protection against unauthorised disclosure and request the return of items that are no longer needed for the relevant proceedings.
  7. Put internal procedures in place before an inspection occurs. Designate responsible personnel, train employees and ensure that confidential information is properly labelled and protected within the company.

Protecting a company and its trade secrets effectively starts long before inspectors arrive. Well-prepared employees, clear internal procedures and timely legal assistance can determine whether an unannounced inspection proceeds without unnecessary complications and whether the company succeeds in safeguarding its most valuable business information.


Dawn Raids in Europe: Further Articles in the Series
As part of our European Dawn Raid series, our colleagues in Poland have published an article exploring how trade secrets can be protected during dawn raids. The article is available on the Polish RÖDL website: Dawn Raid in Poland: Protection of Trade Secrets | Rödl

Further articles covering Germany, the Czech Republic and Italy will follow, offering insights into the legal aspects of dawn raids and the protection of trade secrets in each jurisdiction.

Kontakt

Contact Person Picture

Jakub Šotník

Attorney at Law (Czechia)

Partner

+420 236 163 210

Send inquiry

Skip Ribbon Commands
Skip to main content
Deutschland Weltweit Search Menu